Investing
Coca-Cola Shares Up 37% in 2026, but Earnings Growth Trails Far Behind
By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.
Coca-Cola shares have closed at all-time highs more than two dozen times in 2026, and the stock is up roughly 37% from its 2025 year-end level of $69.91, according to The Motley Fool. If that gain holds through December, it would be the largest single-year advance for the stock since 1996, when shares rose about 42%.
The most recent record closes came on Oct. 16, Oct. 22 and Nov. 2, hitting $93.90, $95.34 and $95.83 respectively, with shares trading near $96 at the time of the Motley Fool piece. None of those records were accompanied by new earnings results or a revised company forecast.
What the earnings actually show
Coca-Cola management now expects comparable earnings per share, the company's preferred adjusted profit measure, to grow at least 11% in 2026 from a 2025 base of $3.00. That is a genuine acceleration. The Motley Fool notes that comparable earnings per share grew between 7% and 8% annually from 2022 through 2024, then slowed to 4% in 2025, weighed down by a five-point currency headwind. This year, currency has flipped to a tailwind, contributing roughly three points to the growth rate.
But the earnings revision since February tells a more modest story. At the start of the year, management guided for 7% to 8% comparable earnings-per-share growth, implying roughly $3.21 to $3.24 a share. The current guidance of at least 11% growth implies at least $3.33. That is an upward revision of about 3% to the earnings outlook. The stock, over the same period, has risen about 25%.
The Motley Fool's reading is that most of this year's share price gain reflects investors paying a higher multiple for each dollar of earnings, not earnings growth itself. Measuring year-end share prices against that year's comparable earnings per share, the piece notes the stock traded around 26 times earnings at the close of both 2021 and 2022, fell to roughly 22 times in 2023 and 2024, and ended 2025 at about 23 times earnings.
What the quarterly results showed
CNBC reported Coca-Cola's third-quarter 2024 results, in which the company posted adjusted earnings per share of 77 cents against analyst expectations of 74 cents, and revenue of $11.95 billion adjusted against an expected $11.60 billion. Shares had climbed 18% at that point in 2024, lifting the company's market value to nearly $300 billion.
A Nasdaq.com piece from that period noted that earlier in 2024, Coca-Cola had lifted its quarterly dividend 5.4% to $0.485 per share, the company's 62nd straight year of annual dividend growth.
A separate SEC filing covering second-quarter 2024 results showed that while reported earnings per share fell 5% to $0.56, comparable EPS on a non-GAAP basis grew 7% to $0.84, with an 11-point currency impact weighing on the reported figure.
What the valuation gap means
The practical question for investors is whether the current price already reflects the best plausible earnings scenario. At roughly $96 a share and guidance of at least $3.33 in comparable earnings per share for 2026, the stock is trading at close to 29 times that adjusted figure, well above the 22-to-23 times range where it spent 2023 through 2025.
The Motley Fool's author said the stock would need to fall closer to $80 before warranting a buy, and noted that the roughly 5% gain since third-quarter results were posted came with no new fundamental information. Whether the multiple expansion is justified depends on how durable the currency tailwind proves and whether earnings growth can sustain the 11%-plus pace beyond this year, neither of which the current guidance settles.
Sources
1. Coca-Cola Stock Keeps Setting Records. I'm Still Not Buying It., fool.com
2. COCA COLA CO - Form 8-K - FY2024, sec.gov
3. Coca-Cola KO Q3 2024 earnings, cnbc.com
4. Coca-Cola Has a Lot to Prove on Oct. 23. Here's Why Investors Should Take Note., nasdaq.com
Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.