Investing
Two Vanguard Funds, One Retirement Portfolio: The Case Bogle Made That Wall Street Dismissed
By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.
Two Vanguard index funds can make a complete retirement portfolio: Total Stock Market Admiral Shares (VTSAX) for the whole US stock market and Total Bond Market Admiral Shares (VBTLX) for US investment-grade bonds. The pair is cheap and hard to mismanage, but the bond half has lost money over the last five and ten years, and the portfolio holds no international stocks and no inflation-protected bonds.
Take a retiree who put $1 million into the two funds five years ago, $600,000 in stocks and $400,000 in bonds, and left it alone. Using the funds' dividend-adjusted returns through November 17, 2026, according to 24/7 Wall St, the stock half grew 45.92% to about $875,500 and the bond half fell 16.99% to about $332,000, for a total near $1.21 million before any withdrawals. The bonds cost money over that stretch. What they bought shows up in a bad month: between October 20 and November 20, 2026, VTSAX fell 6.53% while VBTLX rose 0.32%, so the same $1 million mix would have dropped to about $962,000, against about $935,000 for $1 million held entirely in stocks.
What the two funds are
VTSAX holds large, mid and small US companies by tracking the CRSP US Total Market Index. Its annual expense ratio, the fee taken directly from fund assets each year, is 0.04%, which works out to $400 on a $1 million balance. Its ten largest positions are dominated by megacap technology companies, so a handful of names drive a large share of results.
VBTLX tracks the Bloomberg US Aggregate Float Adjusted Index, a mix of Treasury bonds, investment-grade corporate bonds and mortgage-backed securities. Both funds have historically carried a $3,000 minimum investment, and brokerages other than Vanguard may charge a transaction fee to buy Vanguard mutual funds.
The low-cost idea behind them is John Bogle's. His first index fund was dismissed as Bogle's Folly when it launched in 1976, raising a little more than $11 million, and his case was that costs come straight out of returns, so the lowest-cost owner of the market keeps more of what the market delivers.
Why the bond fund lost money
VBTLX was down 4.41% this year to date and 4.60% over one year, and down 16.99% over five years and 13.11% over ten, while VTSAX gained 223.96% over the same ten years. The five-year loss reflects the sharp rise in interest rates that began in 2022: when rates rise, existing bond prices fall, and a fund that holds the whole bond market takes the full weight of that move. Diversification shrinks losses; it does not prevent them.
Where the bonds earn their place
The danger for a retiree is a steep market fall early in retirement while withdrawals are already underway, known as sequence-of-returns risk. Selling shares at depressed prices to pay living expenses permanently reduces the portfolio's ability to recover, which is why a bad first year does far more damage than a bad fifteenth year. The standard response is to draw withdrawals from the bond fund after a stock decline, giving stocks time to recover before they are touched. Rebalancing once a year, or whenever the split drifts several percentage points off target, keeps the stock and bond shares from creeping too far in either direction; neither fund does it for you.
Before using it
Check two numbers: how many years of withdrawals the bond share would cover without selling stocks in a downturn, and what your brokerage charges to buy these funds. If you want international stocks or inflation protection, the pair does not supply them.
Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.