Investing
Amazon's Cloud Pulls Ahead as Alphabet's Search Business Faces AI Pressure
By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.
Amazon and Alphabet are both pouring capital into artificial intelligence infrastructure, but their stock performance this year tells a diverging story. Amazon shares are up roughly 13.5% in 2026, ahead of the broader market, while Alphabet is down roughly 10.6%, according to The Motley Fool.
Both companies are hyperscalers, a term for businesses that run the world's largest cloud computing networks and rent that computing power to other companies. Both are investing heavily in the data centers that AI systems require. But the risks sitting beneath each investment are different, and that difference is what the gap in their stock performance reflects.
What the cloud numbers show
Amazon Web Services, Amazon's cloud division, generated nearly $46 billion in third-quarter revenue, a gain of more than 39% compared with the same period a year earlier. The segment's operating margin, meaning the share of revenue left after operating costs, came in at nearly 39% for the quarter. Amazon has guided its 2026 capital expenditure to around $220 billion, and the company is currently running negative free cash flow, meaning its spending on new infrastructure exceeds the cash its operations generate, as those projects build out.
Alphabet's Google Cloud division brought in roughly $30.7 billion in the third quarter, more than double the figure from the same quarter in 2025. Alphabet is expected to spend between $195 billion and $205 billion this year on AI infrastructure, and management has said capital expenditure will rise further in 2027. Like Amazon, Alphabet is currently generating negative free cash flow from these investments.
The harder question for Alphabet
The cloud growth at both companies is real, but the more pressing issue for Alphabet is what AI is doing to Google's core search business, which accounts for the bulk of company revenue. Search revenue grew 12% year over year in the third quarter, a pace that has slowed from recent quarters.
Alphabet's chief business officer Philipp Schindler addressed the dynamic directly on the earnings call: "The strong growth in AI Mode queries had an impact because of the lower monetization we were seeing in AI Mode." In plain terms, users are getting answers through AI-powered search without clicking on the ads that generate Google's revenue.
Google has held a reported 90% share of the traditional search market. That kind of dominance is unlikely to carry over into AI search, which also faces pressure from open-weight models, meaning AI systems whose underlying code is publicly available and that anyone can run without paying Google. That is the central concern weighing on the stock.
Amazon's AI risk is narrower
Amazon faces its own AI challenge on the e-commerce side. AI shopping agents, such as Meta Platforms' Muse, can complete purchases without exposing users to ads, which threatens Amazon's advertising revenue. Amazon has responded by blocking Muse from its platform. Rosenblatt analyst Scott Devitt noted that third-party agents lack data on Amazon's inventory, which gives Amazon some leverage in that standoff.
Amazon is also using AI to personalize the shopping experience and is benefiting from physical AI through warehouse robotics, with drone delivery and self-driving logistics as longer-term possibilities the source mentions but does not quantify.
What to watch
The Motley Fool's Bram Berkowitz, who wrote the piece and discloses no position in any of the stocks mentioned, views the AI challenges as more manageable for Amazon and the threat to Google's search business as the bigger open question. That is his interpretation, not an established fact.
The specific number worth tracking each quarter is the monetization gap between traditional search and AI Mode at Google: whether it narrows or widens will shape whether Alphabet's discount to Amazon persists. On the Amazon side, the question is whether its heavy capital spending translates into sustained margin expansion at AWS. Alphabet's management has said the infrastructure investments will generate meaningful returns once complete, but investors, as the Motley Fool notes, have their doubts.
Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.