Investing
S&P 500 Breaks Below Its November Low. What to Do and What to Avoid.
By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.
The S&P 500 has broken below the low it set during the sharp November 5 sell-off, reaching its weakest point since mid-June, according to The Motley Fool. Columnist James Brumley argues the move is not the start of a new bear market but does mark a meaningful change in the bull market's character, one he ties largely to a broad repricing of artificial intelligence stocks after years of outsized enthusiasm.
What the shift looks like
Brumley's read is that the sectors and strategies that drove gains from 2023 through early 2026 may not lead the next leg. AI-related names, which he describes as must-haves through that stretch, have shown recent weakness he interprets as a sign that the peak of AI enthusiasm has passed. Consumer staples, which lagged during the same period, have been drawing investor interest in 2026 as a perceived safe haven. The practical implication, in his view, is that sector positioning matters more now than it did when a rising tide was lifting most boats.
The three steps
First, Brumley recommends reviewing every holding against a single question: would you want to own it through the next bear market so you hold it at the start of the next bull market? Names that fail that test, he argues, are worth selling now even at a loss, because a weaker market makes their recovery harder, not easier.
Second, he recommends building a watch list of companies you would want to own at the beginning of a recovery, set aside from any concern about recent price performance. The point is to be ready to buy when sentiment is worst, which is when most investors are selling.
Third, he stresses holding enough cash to act on that list without being forced to sell something else under pressure. Decisions made under stress, he notes, tend to be poor ones.
The one thing he is not doing
Brumley is explicit that he is not selling broadly out of fear. His concern is not the losses themselves but missing the early days of a recovery. To support that, he cites data from Hartford, a mutual fund company, which puts the average S&P 500 gain in the first month of a new bull market at 13.6% and the average gain over the first three months at 25.3%, against a full bull market average of 114%. Those figures, he argues, show that the market can move sharply and quickly in ways that punish investors who are sitting on the sidelines.
What this analysis does not establish
Brumley is clear that his view, including the forecast that the economy will avoid recession and the market will avoid a full bear market, is his own judgment, not a verified outcome. The Hartford figures describe historical averages across past cycles; they say nothing about the timing or magnitude of the next one. His sector observations, including the rotation away from AI and toward consumer staples, are his interpretation of recent price behavior, not a confirmed trend with measured data behind it. Investors weighing his framework should treat the directional calls as one analyst's read, not a consensus.
The practical question worth sitting with: which holdings in your portfolio would you genuinely want to own through a prolonged downturn, and which ones are you holding on hope? That distinction, more than any market call, is what Brumley's framework is actually asking you to make.
Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.