Investing
Oakmark's Large Cap ETF Carries a High Earnings Yield but a Weak Upside Record
By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.
The Oakmark U.S. Large Cap ETF, which trades under the ticker OAKM, is an actively managed fund built around intrinsic value investing. A Seeking Alpha analyst is keeping a Hold rating on the fund, a position first assigned in February 2025 and unchanged after a fresh review.
What the fund does well
OAKM has outperformed the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV), a widely used benchmark for large-cap US equities, over a recent stretch. The analyst attributes that to the fund's heavy weighting in financial and healthcare stocks, which carry strong value characteristics and relatively low volatility. On an earnings yield basis, meaning how much a company earns relative to its share price, the fund scores well.
Where it falls short
The problem is what happens when markets move higher. The analyst puts OAKM's historical upside capture ratio at 88.3% against IVV. An upside capture ratio measures how much of a benchmark's gains a fund captures during rising markets: a reading below 100% means the fund tends to trail when the broader market rallies. At 88.3%, the gap is meaningful enough to matter over a full market cycle.
The fund is also described as too light in growth exposure, with no discernible edge over IVV on GARP metrics. GARP, or growth at a reasonable price, is a framework that looks for companies growing faster than average but not trading at extreme valuations. Without that edge, the analyst expects the fund's returns to lag going forward.
What the SEC filing adds
A Form N-CSR filed with the SEC covers the fund's fiscal year ending September 30, 2025, and includes cost disclosures based on a hypothetical $10,000 investment, though the filing as available does not provide enough detail to draw further conclusions about performance or holdings beyond what the analyst's piece establishes.
The practical trade-off
OAKM offers genuine value characteristics and a high earnings yield, which can provide a degree of cushion in down markets. What it does not offer, based on the historical record, is the ability to keep pace with a rising market. For an investor already holding broad index exposure through something like IVV, adding OAKM does not clearly improve the growth side of the portfolio. For an investor specifically seeking active management with a value and low-volatility tilt, the fund is worth watching, but the analyst stops short of recommending it.
The key thing to check: whether the fund's sector mix shifts meaningfully toward growth over coming quarters, and whether its upside capture ratio improves as the portfolio evolves. Neither is visible yet in the current data.
Sources
1. OAKM: High Earnings Yield, Decent Quality, But Unlikely To Outperform, Hold Maintained, seekingalpha.com
2. Harris Oakmark ETF Trust - Form N-CSR - FY2025, sec.gov
Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.