Investing
An Investor Who Called the Silicon Valley Bank Collapse Is Now Betting Against Berkshire Hathaway and SpaceX
By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.
Bill Martin, who runs Raging Capital Ventures and gained attention for predicting the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank in 2023, has disclosed short positions in both Berkshire Hathaway and SpaceX, according to The Motley Fool. A short position is a bet that a stock will fall in price. Martin made the disclosure through his Raging Capital Ventures account on X.
Geoffrey Seiler, a Motley Fool analyst who previously worked as a senior equity analyst at Martin's hedge fund before it closed, writes that he is not following either trade, and explains why below.
The Berkshire short
Martin's position on Berkshire Hathaway is built around valuation and concern about the insurance business. He purchased Berkshire B-share March $550 put options for a little over $10. A put option gives the buyer the right to sell shares at a set price, and buying puts is one way to profit if a stock falls. Martin described the out-of-the-money puts (options whose target price is below the current market price) as a low-cost way to take on a large notional short position, meaning he is putting up a relatively small amount of money to bet against a large dollar value of stock.
His view is that the stock's price-to-book ratio, a measure that compares a company's share price to the net value of its assets, has climbed from roughly 1.4 earlier this year to about 1.6, and that the insurance operation is showing early signs of weakness. He has also expressed skepticism about Greg Abel, who succeeded Warren Buffett as chief executive earlier this year.
Seiler writes that the 1.6 price-to-book ratio is somewhat elevated but not out of line with where Berkshire has traded over the past three years. His view is that long-term holders can stay comfortable, though he would not be adding at current levels. He notes that Berkshire's large cash position continues to give it a safe-haven quality.
The SpaceX short
Martin's SpaceX thesis centers on ownership concentration and regulatory exposure. His argument, as Seiler describes it, is that the stock is already widely held across endowment funds and venture capital firms, leaving few new buyers to push the price higher. Martin also pointed to the capital intensity of SpaceX's growth plans and the competitive nature of the markets those plans target.
The regulatory dimension is the most specific part of the case. Martin argues that SpaceX's largest growth engine is terrestrial data centers, where permitting conditions are expected to tighten. A domestic mobile network would require Federal Communications Commission approval, and the space launch business depends on Federal Aviation Administration licenses. Martin also cited the midterm elections as a setback for Elon Musk, who backed largely unsuccessful Republican candidates, potentially reducing the political capital SpaceX needs for ventures requiring government sign-off.
One counterpoint Seiler raises: a slower overall buildout of artificial intelligence infrastructure could actually benefit SpaceX. The company earns premium pricing on short-term AI infrastructure rentals, and if industry-wide computing capacity grows more slowly than expected, those rental prices could stay elevated.
What this does and does not establish
Martin's track record on short calls is real, but a single disclosed position is not a verdict on either company. The Berkshire valuation argument is straightforward to evaluate: the price-to-book ratio is a public figure and investors can judge for themselves whether 1.6 times book represents a stretched entry point.
The SpaceX case is harder to assess independently because the company is not publicly listed, and ownership data is not available the way it would be for a stock trading on an exchange.
Seiler is explicit that he would not recommend shorting to individual investors, given the structural risks of short selling and the long-run tendency of quality companies to appreciate in price. For holders of either name, the practical question is whether Martin's specific concerns, particularly the insurance softening at Berkshire and the permitting environment at SpaceX, show up in upcoming company disclosures and earnings commentary. Those are the concrete things worth watching.
Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.