Money

Costco's Pokemon Card Frenzy Is Minting Membership Fees, Not Resale Profits

By Bear Creek Staff, . Bear Creek Capital Network.

Costco's Pokemon Card Frenzy Is Minting Membership Fees, Not Resale Profits

Costco's Pokemon card lines have become a minor economy of their own, complete with group tactics, hand-stamping by staff and, according to one account, tips from warehouse employees. The financial winner in all of it is Costco.

Christa DiBiase, co-host of The Clark Howard Podcast, described the scene at her local warehouse on a November 13 episode, as 24/7 Wall St. reported. She had gone in for a vitamin and found a long queue at the returns desk. Staff were scanning shoppers, marking hands and routing people to a separate line with a one-pack limit. She said participants worked in groups, changed clothes to get back in line and swapped cards and credit cards among themselves. She also said resellers were getting "insider information from Costco employees," though she did not verify that claim herself, and her account covers one warehouse.

What Costco earns from the chaos

Every reseller who upgrades to an Executive membership to chase a card drop feeds Costco's highest-margin revenue line. The company closed its fiscal fourth quarter with 42.3 million paid Executive members, a 9% increase, and membership fee income rose 7% to $1.85 billion, according to the report. Executive members made up 76% of fourth-quarter sales, renew at a 92% rate in the US and Canada, and spend more than Gold Star members on average.

On November 10, Costco declared a "$30 per-share special dividend, payable December 4," and renewed a $4 billion stock buyback program. Jim Cramer told CNBC viewers on November 11 that Costco "make their money on the card, not at the register," meaning the membership fee, not the merchandise margin.

Whether the Executive tier pays off for the reseller

The arithmetic is straightforward. A Gold Star membership runs $65 a year. Executive costs $130 and returns 2% on qualifying purchases, capped at $1,250 annually. To earn back the $65 premium, a member needs $3,250 in qualifying purchases over the year. Below that, the upgrade is a net cost.

A reseller spending $1,000 a year at Costco earns $20 in rewards against a $65 upgrade cost, leaving them $45 behind before a single pack is sold. A paid Discord subscription, used to get early notice of card drops, adds to the cost of every pack on top of that.

A household spending $500 a month, or $6,000 a year, earns $120 in rewards and comes out $55 ahead after paying for the upgrade. The full $130 fee is covered only at $6,500 in annual qualifying spending. The $1,250 reward cap does not apply until spending reaches $62,500 a year.

What to check before upgrading or renewing

The decision comes down to one number: actual annual spending at Costco, pulled from account history rather than estimated. Apply the 2% test to qualifying categories only, since some purchases do not earn the reward. If the result is under $3,250, the Gold Star tier is cheaper and the difference stays with the member rather than with Costco.

For anyone buying Executive specifically to pursue card drops, the fixed cost of the upgrade and any Discord fees should be counted against the cost of each pack before calculating resale profit. A one-pack limit spreads those fixed costs across very few cards, which makes the margin on each one thinner than it looks.

Source: https://247wallst.com/personal-finance/2026/11/14/theyre-getting-insider-information-from-costco-employees-inside-the-pokemon-card-line-where-resellers-buy-executive-memberships/

Bear Creek Capital Network publishes content for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing in this article constitutes financial, investment, tax or legal advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

More from Bear Creek Capital Network